Pokémon Red and Blue: which starter should you pick (Bulbasaur, Charmander or Squirtle)?

By Carvalho Games Published on 3 min read
Pokémon Red and Blue: which starter should you pick (Bulbasaur, Charmander or Squirtle)?
In this guide

The very first choice in Pokémon Red and Blue is also the most famous one in the series: in Professor Oak's lab you take home Bulbasaur, Charmander or Squirtle. There is no wrong answer, since you can beat the game with any of them. But each starter changes how hard the first few hours feel.

Quick summary if you are in a hurry:

Starter Type Early game Best for
Bulbasaur Grass/Poison Very easy First-time players
Charmander Fire Hard Players who want a challenge
Squirtle Water Easy and balanced A steady team

Bulbasaur: the smoothest start

Bulbasaur is the "easy mode" pick for the first half of the game. The first two gym leaders use exactly the types Grass beats:

  • Brock (Pewter City) uses Rock/Ground Pokémon such as Geodude and Onix. Grass moves deal double damage to them.
  • Misty (Cerulean City) uses Water Pokémon such as Staryu and Starmie. Grass has the edge again.

Bulbasaur also learns Leech Seed early, draining the opponent every turn. Then come Vine Whip, Sleep Powder and Razor Leaf. Razor Leaf lands critical hits very often in this generation, which makes it one of the best early moves in the game.

Weak spot: because it is also Poison-type, Bulbasaur (and later Ivysaur and Venusaur) struggles against Psychic Pokémon, which are very strong in Red and Blue. Sabrina's gym and some Elite Four members will call for other team members.

Charmander: challenge mode

Charmander has the toughest road early on, because both of the first gyms resist Fire. Against Brock, Ember only does half damage to Rock. Against Misty, Fire is the type at a disadvantage.

How to get through anyway:

  1. Train a little before Brock. A few extra levels make a huge difference early on.
  2. Build a support team. Catch Pokémon on Route 22 and in Viridian Forest and use whoever has the advantage in each fight.
  3. Use Growl to weaken the opponent before you attack.

The payoff comes later: Charmander evolves into Charmeleon and, at level 36, into Charizard, which learns Flamethrower and becomes a very strong attacker. It shines against Erika (Grass) and also has the edge over Bug-type Pokémon.

Squirtle: the balanced pick

Squirtle is the "no surprises" choice. Against Brock, Bubble gets the job done: Water is super effective against Rock and Ground. Against Misty the matchup is neutral, but easy with a bit of training.

In its final form, Blastoise has solid defense and strong Water moves, and can learn moves of other types through TMs. It is the starter that relies least on the rest of your team to keep going. It is also a big help against Blaine (Fire) and Giovanni (Ground).

Which starter helps in each gym

Gym Type Best starter
Brock Rock Bulbasaur or Squirtle
Misty Water Bulbasaur
Lt. Surge Electric Bulbasaur (resists Electric)
Erika Grass Charmander
Koga Poison None stands out, bring a Psychic or Ground type
Sabrina Psychic None stands out, do not rely on Bulbasaur
Blaine Fire Squirtle
Giovanni Ground Bulbasaur or Squirtle

Our recommendation

  • First time playing Pokémon? Go with Bulbasaur. The start is easy and you learn the game without getting stuck on Brock.
  • Already beat it and want some excitement? Charmander makes the first hours much more demanding.
  • Want a steady team from start to finish? Squirtle.

Tip: your rival always picks the starter that has the advantage over yours. If you take Bulbasaur, he goes with Charmander. Have a Water or Rock Pokémon ready for those fights.

Into hero collecting and turn-based battles? Check out our list of the best Super Nintendo RPGs.